Siân Berry MP: speeches
4 Jul 2026–18 Nov 2026 · year in progress
How these years work
Our reporting years run from 4 July to 3 July, starting with the 2024 general election. They are not official parliamentary sessions. Office costs keep IPSA’s April–March financial years. Records may cover only part of a year; a missing record does not mean no work was done.
Parliamentary contributions: dates and coverage
- Source checked
- 17 Nov 2026
- Last successful import
- 17 Nov 2026
- Records dated through
- 16 Nov 2026
- Selected period
- Reporting year 3: 4 Jul 2026 to 18 Nov 2026
- Completeness
- Published snapshot: 19,524 records in the source window 19 Aug 2026 to 17 Nov 2026. The published snapshot covers its stated source window. Older imports can extend beyond it; not every public speech is included.
This page lists the parliamentary spoken contributions we hold for Siân Berry in the reporting year 3 (4 Jul 2026 to 18 Nov 2026). It does not include every public speech, party-conference address or constituency event. Latest retained contribution in this period: 3 Nov 2026. The source check date and dataset limits are shown above. Open the Hansard link for the full debate and surrounding context.
Read what this MP said, asked and contributed in Parliament.
228 published records · newest first.
Speeches
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
All I am pointing out is that the Home Office’s record on this kind of thing is not brilliant, and that there exists a body far more appropriate than the Government’s proposal for direct appointments. I do not quite understand why Members are arguing so hard against that, when I am certain that the Judicial Appointments Commission would be happy to take up the role.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I appreciate that, and I have laid out the possible alternative remedies, but judicial review is an essential backstop. I do not see why the Government are trying to remove it. This is constitutionally exceptional and I want the Minister to explain why it is okay. This measure will not only undermine the rule of law; it will inevitably provoke litigation in the courts about how this ouster clause should be interpreted and effected.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I disagree. I think that the Government are focusing on the wrong part of the system here. As MPs, we are all aware of the processes involved in the initial decision making of the Home Office.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
I appreciate the hon. Member’s laying out the process, but can he honestly say that, if he were subjected to any area of justice, he would accept those arguments and the process for taking away his right to appeal twice, which the amendment would effect? Does he believe that that genuinely represents justice without fear or favour?
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I agree about the growth in the backlog, but as I said earlier, the analysis is pretty clear that that growth comes from an increase in refusals as well as the increasing speed with which the Home Office is making decisions. To me, those two things go together. The increase in refusals is likely to represent an increase in mistaken refusals—refusals that should not have happened. We cannot get away with just looking at the proportions here, either.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I have very nearly finished, so I will press on. At its heart, the IIAA fundamentally represents another ill-thought-through Government proposal to create a truncated legal process. It is part of the previous Prime Minister’s misconceived attempts to pander to the disturbing ideas of Reform UK and its even more unsettling offshoot, Restore Britain.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Amendment 65 to clause 1 would allow judicial review of decisions. It would remove the provision in the Bill that excludes all judicial review of IIAA appeal decisions. Clause 1(8) is a so-called ouster clause, as the explanatory notes confirm. It is designed to immunise the IIAA’s appeal decisions from judicial review in the High Court. The purpose of the amendment is to remove the Government’s attempt to undermine the rule of law.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
I beg to move amendment 65, in clause 1, page 2, leave out lines 11 to 14. This amendment would remove the provision which prevents individuals from being able to initiate judicial review proceedings against decisions made by the IIAA.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I am not convinced by anything I have heard from the Minister. She talked about my amendments not allowing flexibility, but let us be clear what she has said: she is asking for flexibility in fairness, but not flexibility in the political definition of public interest. The risk to human rights here is huge. Let us not forget that these are life and death decisions for people who are among the most vulnerable in the world.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
On a point of clarification, is it not correct that under clause 7 the upper tribunal can hear an appeal only based on a point of law? Will the Minister comment on the way that challenging the processes or the administration of someone’s claim could therefore not be taken to the upper tribunal? Is she removing that safeguard?
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I will speak to why clause 1 and schedule 1 should not form part of the Bill. Although I will not speak to every clause, all these reasons equally apply to the rest of part 1, which deals with the creation and implementation of the IIAA. It is a real shame that this policy has not yet become another U-turn from this Administration.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I do not agree with that at all. This body will be making legal decisions. I will talk in a moment about how the chief executive and chair, who will be under the Home Office’s wing, will not be legally qualified to make those appointments. I cannot understand why every single safeguard should not be introduced in the Bill. Furthermore, this is a judicial process, so why should it not be the Judicial Appointments Commission?
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
I beg to move amendment 66, in clause 2, page 2, leave out lines 24 to 28 and insert— “(2) The executive and non-executive members of the IIAA specified in subsection (1) are to be appointed by the Judicial Appointments Commission.” This amendment would require the Chair, Chief Executive, Chief Appeals Officer, Professional Standards Officer and adjudicators of the IIAA to be appointed by the Judicial Appointments Commission.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I will speak to amendment 66, about the appointments process to the IIAA, and amendment 67, about the legal qualifications and experience of adjudicators. Under the Bill, the chair of the IIAA will be a Home Office appointee. The chair will decide the IIAA’s chief executive, who will then appoint adjudicators. By contrast, I believe that the leadership and decision-making roles in the IIAA should be decided by the Judicial Appointments Commission, the body that appoints judges.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
It is a pleasure to have you in the Chair, Dr Murrison. I am moving amendment 64, to make fairness and efficiency duties of the Independent Immigration Appeals Authority. I should add that in this group I also support amendments 48 and 49, tabled by my Lib Dem colleagues, I oppose amendment 87 tabled by my Conservative colleagues and I support the Lib Dems’ new clause 12.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
The hon. Member is right that, sometimes, appointments of supposedly independent commissioners are made—I had experience of that recently in relation to equalities—but there is often a political element to the appointment and the direction they seem to take. We must always appreciate that and guard against it.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I beg to move amendment 64, in clause 1, page 2, leave out lines 1 to 5 and insert— “(5) In the exercise of its functions, the IIAA must— (a) be accessible, fair and independent, (b) handle its cases quickly and efficiently.” This amendment would remove the requirement for the IIAA to “aim to” operate fairly and independently and handle cases quickly and efficiently, so that the IIAA instead has a duty to so act.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
As I am sure the hon. Member will have imagined, I cannot agree, given the number of cases overturned. We have had some data from the Minister in her letter of 6 October, and 44% of human rights appeals are being allowed. Those are appeals where the initial decision was wrong.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Fourth sitting) · Hansard source
More
The Minister said, “efficiency and effectiveness”. One of the issues that I raised was equalities issues and discrimination. Will that also be in the remit?
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Fourth sitting) · Hansard source
More
My arguments were not that it should be longer, but that it should be the right amount of time to achieve fairness and justice. I am sure that the hon. Member for Isle of Wight East would not disagree that the right amount of time is essential, and that shorter is not necessarily better.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Fourth sitting) · Hansard source
More
I beg to move amendment 63, in clause 4, page 4, line 21, leave out “have regard to the desirability of” and insert “do so with a view to”. This amendment would make the requirements relating to the IIAA Procedure Board equivalent to those of the Tribunal Procedure Committee when exercising its power to make rules.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Fourth sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I beg to move amendment 83, in clause 8, page 6, line 32, leave out “the IIAA” and insert “individuals and organisations with an interest in how the IIAA operates, including— (a) the IIAA, (b) people granted protection status, (c) people with lived experience of the asylum system, (d) legal practitioners and organisations representing the interests of people with, or seeking, protection status, and (e) such other persons as the Secretary of State considers appropriate.”
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Fourth sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Clause 8 allows the Secretary of State to set time limits for the work of the IIAA. That is in notable contrast to all the claims of independence, and I think it is very wrong to do that. My amendment 83 therefore expands the list of people whom the Secretary of State must consult before making those regulations, although I would still be against the clause as a whole.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Fourth sitting) · Hansard source
More
I will not labour the point any further. I will press my amendment to a Division, and I hope the Minister will keep looking at how this kind of consultation can be made more statutorily inclusive. Question p ut, That the amendment be made.
- 13 Oct 2026 · Immigration and Asylum Bill (Fourth sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
The Bill currently states that the IIAA procedure rules board must “have regard to the desirability of” ensuring that justice is done and that it is accessible, fair and independent. The amendment would simply strengthen that duty and ensure that it must act “with a view to” securing those things rather than merely considering them “desirable”.
Explore activity by topic or department
Contributions by debate topic
4 Jul 2026–18 Nov 2026. Existing keyword taxonomy applied to official debate titles and contributions; a contribution may appear in more than one topic and unclassified records are retained.
View as listWhat this shows and doesn't show
Published records only — not a full account of an MP’s work. How we work →