Meg Hillier MP: speeches
4 Jul 2024–3 Jul 2025
How these years work
Our reporting years run from 4 July to 3 July, starting with the 2024 general election. They are not official parliamentary sessions. Office costs keep IPSA’s April–March financial years. Records may cover only part of a year; a missing record does not mean no work was done.
Parliamentary contributions: dates and coverage
- Source checked
- 19 Nov 2026
- Last successful import
- 19 Nov 2026
- Records dated through
- 18 Nov 2026
- Selected period
- Reporting year 1: 4 Jul 2024 to 3 Jul 2025
- Completeness
- Published snapshot: 20,988 records in the source window 21 Aug 2026 to 19 Nov 2026. The published snapshot covers its stated source window. Older imports can extend beyond it; not every public speech is included.
This page lists the parliamentary spoken contributions we hold for Meg Hillier in the reporting year 1 (4 Jul 2024 to 3 Jul 2025). It does not include every public speech, party-conference address or constituency event. Latest retained contribution in this period: 25 Apr 2025. The source check date and dataset limits are shown above. Open the Hansard link for the full debate and surrounding context.
Read what this MP said, asked and contributed in Parliament.
24 published records · newest first.
Speeches
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I congratulate the hon. Member for Arbroath and Broughty Ferry (Stephen Gethins) on bringing forward this Bill. It takes me back to the halcyon days when I served as an immigration Minister. I am delighted to have the opportunity to speak about that experience and explain why I therefore disagree with the premise of his Bill. There were things the hon. Gentleman said that we might find agreement on. He says that migration is a good thing.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
My hon. Friend is right. We have seen the pain and challenges caused by Brexit for academic movement. Knowledge has no boundaries or borders, but there is a danger of the Bill not recognising that. Let me turn to the Scottish National party’s proposal for a Scottish graduate visa. Overseas students in the UK can get a two-year graduate visa.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
My right hon. Friend is making an interesting point about the challenges facing rural areas where there are shortages of people. Denmark has a rota system for doctors going into rural areas for a few months at a time, because it, like Scotland and parts of England, have these challenges. Does my right hon. Friend therefore agree that having a separate immigration policy for Scotland is not the answer and that this issue is being grappled with across the world?
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Certainly, it would not be cost-free. It would be a big burden on taxpayers across the UK, whichever tax system they were in. The hon. Member for Perth and Kinross-shire talked about using a tax code as a marker of whether people had moved. Has he not heard of working from home, or working on holiday? That is a trend that I have read about. People can be working for an employer in one country but living somewhere else.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
My hon. Friend makes the point well. We could reopen the whole debate about the Windsor framework, the border in the Irish sea and the many challenges to do with that, but I will not try your patience, Madam Deputy Speaker. When I was Chair of the Public Accounts Committee, we looked a lot at the detail of that, including the costs and the complication.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
I completely agree with my hon. Friend. Of course, there is another leader in this world who has talked about building a wall.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Unbelievable as it may seem to the hon. Gentleman, I was a Minister between 2007 and 2010. I was a child Minister, of course. [ Laughter. ] I can understand his confusion, but that was the case at the time, and it continued for some while, because I then dealt with the local Member of Parliament—by then I was in opposition—about the challenges of that particular route.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
Absolutely. A lot of tripe was talked at the time about having virtual borders. Even with some of the tensions between Scotland and the UK, which were evident in what SNP Members said earlier, we are not, I hope, at the point where we would have watchtowers and border guards with guns, but once we have a border, that is a risk.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
That is exactly the point. The hon. Member for Arbroath and Broughty Ferry puts great faith in Committee stages. I have been here a long time, and they are not always as good as people say that they will be. Even if there was a Committee stage, there are so many other elements. That is one of the challenges with a Bill that is simply one line long.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
My hon. Friend is right to again highlight the failures of the Scottish Government, which is one of the reasons that people are not staying. We know that this is a challenge, and not just in Scotland. Areas of England have also been left behind and have challenges in keeping their young populations. A lot of work is being done in places such as west Cumbria, where people who left for university outside the area tended not to come back.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Absolutely. My hon. Friend makes the point clearly and powerfully. As he has highlighted, there are other areas that the Bill would affect; it is not simply about setting a new immigration policy. There are a raft of contradictions that could play out in the mechanics behind it, making life very chaotic. I will address that point in more detail later.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
My hon. Friend makes the point.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
Or an Isle of Wight visa! I give way.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
The hon. Gentleman skirted over the question of the cost of doing this. The burden is not the individuals, but there is a huge cost to the UK Home Office of delivering the system and helping people through it—everything from detention centres at airports and elsewhere, to the processing of the claims, the greeting and receiving of people when they sadly arrive on boats and by other routes, and the management of the borders.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
As ever, my hon. Friend talks enormous sense. Let us talk through the practicalities of the proposal that I have just outlined. A person graduating from a Scottish university would be able to stay on and work in Scotland without sponsorship for four years in total. To remind the House, that means two years on a UK graduate visa—or three for a PhD—followed by two years on a Scottish graduate visa.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
If the cap fits, maybe the hon. Gentleman should consider his position. I am not suggesting for a minute that we would see border guards and towers, but once there is a land border there is a risk. We have seen in other parts of the world and among allies of ours more recently quite intemperate discussion about borders, walls and security. We would not want to go down that route.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I have been listening with great interest to the hon. Gentleman. We see from other countries that there are ways of dealing with the issue without having full devolution, for many of the reasons that my hon. Friend the Member for Isle of Wight West (Mr Quigley) laid out. As was highlighted earlier, the Home Secretary made the Scottish Government an offer to work with the Migration Advisory Committee on solutions.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
As you know, Madam Deputy Speaker, it is important that we have debate in this place. People have made points to me and I am simply responding to those points. As I said, I am not suggesting that we would want, or would see, watchtowers with armed guards, and in my area of the country we had the second-largest anti-Brexit vote, so I know where I and my constituents stand on that issue.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I hope that I am beginning to explain how some of these interactions— [ Laughter. ] I am only just beginning. [Hon. Members: “More!”] I fear I might be cut off, which is a great shame, because I had really looked forward to going into this in more detail. If the person completed undergraduate and postgraduate in Scotland, they would qualify for permanent residence simply by having been in the country.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
My hon. Friend has hit the nail on the head. I absolutely take what the hon. Member for Arbroath and Broughty Ferry highlighted. As I said, there are really challenging issues with the demographics in the Scottish population. We all need to put our shoulder to the wheel to deal with those things, rather than saying, “If only the SNP Scottish Government were in charge of immigration, it would all be fine.” This Bill is a gimmick, and the hon.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Hansard source
More
I give way to a former member of the Committee, who looked at those details, too.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Indeed. My hon. Friend was not an MP when we were discussing Brexit, but oh my word, there was a lack of thought about the issues with the land border prior to that.
- 25 Apr 2025 · Devolution (Immigration) (Scotland) Bill · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
My hon. Friend took the words out of my mouth; he says it better than I could. Let me turn for a moment to what the SNP-led Scottish Government wish to deliver. In 2020—I think this was referred to—they published a paper arguing for some devolution of immigration policy to Scotland.
- 21 Oct 2024 · St Helena: UK Immigration · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
It is welcome to hear St Helena mentioned in the House.
Explore activity by topic or department
Contributions by debate topic
4 Jul 2024–3 Jul 2025. Existing keyword taxonomy applied to official debate titles and contributions; a contribution may appear in more than one topic and unclassified records are retained.
View as listWhat this shows and doesn't show
Published records only — not a full account of an MP’s work. How we work →