Mark Garnier MP: speeches

Mark Garnier MP: full overview

4 Jul 2025–3 Jul 2026

How these years work

Our reporting years run from 4 July to 3 July, starting with the 2024 general election. They are not official parliamentary sessions. Office costs keep IPSA’s April–March financial years. Records may cover only part of a year; a missing record does not mean no work was done.

Compare reporting years, sessions and IPSA financial years.

Parliamentary contributions: dates and coverage

Source checked
19 Nov 2026
Last successful import
19 Nov 2026
Records dated through
18 Nov 2026
Selected period
Reporting year 2: 4 Jul 2025 to 3 Jul 2026
Completeness
Published snapshot: 20,988 records in the source window 21 Aug 2026 to 19 Nov 2026. The published snapshot covers its stated source window. Older imports can extend beyond it; not every public speech is included.

How to read these datesOfficial source

This page lists the parliamentary spoken contributions we hold for Mark Garnier in the reporting year 2 (4 Jul 2025 to 3 Jul 2026). It does not include every public speech, party-conference address or constituency event. Latest retained contribution in this period: 30 Jun 2026. The source check date and dataset limits are shown above. Open the Hansard link for the full debate and surrounding context.

Clear speech filters

Read what this MP said, asked and contributed in Parliament.

269 published records · newest first.

Speeches

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q That is interesting; I will go and have a think about that one. Both of you manage annuity funds. For the record, I have had a chance to meet representatives of your organisations and have had long discussions about this.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Also, similarly on the equity point: with defined benefit pension schemes, as I mentioned a bit earlier, if you have a deficit, that then appears on the balance sheet. The behavioural outcome of that is that if you are a trustee or from the host company, you would want to avoid the risk—rather like with the BT pension fund, which I think is £7 billion in deficit, and which now restricts the ability of BT to raise money.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Ironically, I met some annuity providers who are enthusiastic to invest in equities, but they told me that they are being prevented from doing so. For example, an investment in the equity of a wind farm is a very good asset, because there are predictable returns from it, contracts for difference in the price, and all the rest of it, but they are not allowed to invest in that because they are not allowed to invest into equities.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q You just triggered another question. Charlotte, can I quickly ask you about the retail distribution review? The retail distribution review came into effect on 1 January 2013. One of the criticisms at the time was that moving from a commission-based model, where IFAs were paid by commission, to being paid by cash, reduced the number of people seeking financial advice from something in the region of more than 50% to something in the region of 9%.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Hansard source
    More

    Or, indeed, when they first start to work. As somebody once said, compound interest is the eighth wonder of the world.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Thank you very much for coming to give evidence. It can be a little intimidating, even for us, to see so many Government Back Benchers sitting across the table. I will start with the most controversial point: the mandation of local government pension schemes when it comes to amalgamation and being forced to go into assets. There are two parts to my question.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Hansard source
    More

    Q I have one final question. The key point, from the point of view of your members and the local government pension scheme, is that the interest of the members should not be trumped by the interest of the wider economy—their interest comes first. Is that right? Zoe Alexander: That is right, but often those things are consistent, and our members would agree with that. Those things are not inconsistent. Rob Yuille: I agree.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q I must ask a question that is perhaps a self beat-up, if you like. There was a disastrous mini-Budget a few years ago under a different Prime Minister—of course, at the time, we got rid of our bad leaders. Did you stress test a scenario such as that? Michelle Osterma n n: Not here in the UK, but as you can tell by my accent, I am not a local.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Chris, following on from the points about derisking and all the rest of it, we heard from Phoenix a little earlier about the value for money framework. Everybody seems to agree that the framework is a good thing because it is going to drive better performance and all the rest of it, with one exception, expressed by Phoenix: the consequences of an intermediate rating.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q I completely agree: I think it is absolutely right that the more money you have, the more negotiating power you have and the more you can diversify risk and all the rest of it. But part of what I am worried about is this: how is anybody going to prove to the regulator that they will have £25 billion of assets under management by 2035? Surely that is an incredibly difficult thing to prove.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q There was an interesting intervention yesterday from the Reform party about local government pensions. I know that is not necessarily part of what we are talking about now, but they made the point that 50 basis points is way too much to charge for assets under management and that it should be 10 basis points instead.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q One of the questions around that is what drives a removal. We heard from previous witnesses that if a host employer puts in more money than is necessary, it seems perfectly reasonable for them to get some of that back.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Hansard source
    More

    If I remember rightly, the Bill allows for the detail to come in afterwards, so we will have a bit of work to do when this is all over. Thank you very much.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Do they know that they can do that? Somebody who is changing jobs quite a lot would not necessarily be the sort of person who is making strategic decisions about their retirement. Ian Cornelius: I think that is right. It probably goes back to dashboards. They are key to helping to increase visibility. That will get people thinking about the choices they can make, how they want to manage their pension and how they can consolidate their pensions.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q So if this clause is passed, we could potentially see a drop-off in the performance of pension funds? Helen Forrest Hall: I am not sure that we would draw a direct correlation, but the point is that it will start to influence investment decisions.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Hansard source
    More

    Q So the key point is that every single investment must be done on a benefit analysis rather than a social good analysis? Councillor Phillips: If you do not do that, I do not know where you are going with your pension investment.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q A previous witness, Michelle Ostermann, made two really interesting related points. One is that, having derisked the UK pensions industry, there is not the appetite to make some of these investments. The second is that other countries are much better at leveraging their pensions industries in order to promote economic growth. Is that something you have looked at, William?

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Minister, thank you for coming to give evidence—we have a long few weeks together. I will start with the evidence we heard from the Deprived Pensioners Association and the Pensions Action Group. I was rather surprised to hear that a fund that had been put aside, worth £14 billion, has now been taken into the Government’s balance sheet, when in fact that money is there to pay for the exact issues that were raised by those two witnesses.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    And you war game it? Michelle Osterma n n: Yes. The biggest variable that we have a hard time predicting in those scenarios is the likelihood of this being used and the manner in which it is used, but we test deep into the tail. We try several scenarios that give us a high probability of it being abused or overused, and the opposite, and we have come out with pretty strong confidence.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Yes, but there is a serious issue here, which is that you are now the Minister for Pensions and in a position to be able to do something about this. We can look back on the last 14 years and have that conversation—let us get that out of the way—but here is your opportunity to resolve this problem.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Helen, can I pick up on your comment that you have to make long-term decisions? These reserve powers have a sunset clause that will apply in 2035. Presumably, if you are making an investment decision, you have to take that into account.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    But you would rather see the opportunities first? Sophia Singleton: Absolutely—we would love to see the opportunities first. Helen Forrest Hall: The other dynamic there is that international pension funds, for example, are often looking to invest in the UK for reasons different from the reasons UK pension funds might want to invest.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Do you think there is a risk that mandation could come in on the LGPS by subtle, behavioural outcomes rather than necessarily through directive outcomes? Rachel Elwell: I can understand why the Government would want to have a backstop power to direct pools, because the LGPS is significant—it is one of the top 10 globally by size. It has an impact on council tax, and on the economy more generally.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q On this derisking thing, a number of investment managers over the years have pointed out to me that the rules were brought in as a result of Maxwell absconding and taking a lot of money out of his pension fund.

  • 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Second sitting) · Hansard source
    More

    Q For defined-benefit pension funds? Morten Nilsson: Yes.

Explore activity by topic or department

Contributions by debate topic

4 Jul 2025–3 Jul 2026. Existing keyword taxonomy applied to official debate titles and contributions; a contribution may appear in more than one topic and unclassified records are retained.

View as listCommunities and local government: 37Communities and local government37Culture, media and sport: 10Culture, media and sport10Defence and foreign affairs: 11Defence and foreign affairs11Democracy and constitution: 36Democracy and constitution36Economy and business: 141Economy and business141Education and skills: 8Education and skills8Environment and energy: 12Environment and energy12Health and care: 3Health and care3Housing and planning: 9Housing and planning9Immigration and borders: 3Immigration and borders3Justice and policing: 17Justice and policing17Social security and pensions: 176Social security and pensions176Transport: 2Transport2Unclassified: 17Unclassified17
What this shows and doesn't show
4 Jul 2025–3 Jul 2026. Existing keyword taxonomy applied to official debate titles and contributions; a contribution may appear in more than one topic and unclassified records are retained. Published records do not measure effort or effectiveness. Methodology.
Department or topicPublished records
Communities and local government37
Culture, media and sport10
Defence and foreign affairs11
Democracy and constitution36
Economy and business141
Education and skills8
Environment and energy12
Health and care3
Housing and planning9
Immigration and borders3
Justice and policing17
Social security and pensions176
Transport2
Unclassified17

Published records only — not a full account of an MP’s work. How we work →