Mark Garnier MP: speeches
Mark Garnier MP: full overview
4 Jul 2025–3 Jul 2026
How these years work
Our reporting years run from 4 July to 3 July, starting with the 2024 general election. They are not official parliamentary sessions. Office costs keep IPSA’s April–March financial years. Records may cover only part of a year; a missing record does not mean no work was done.
Parliamentary contributions: dates and coverage
- Source checked
- 19 Nov 2026
- Last successful import
- 19 Nov 2026
- Records dated through
- 18 Nov 2026
- Selected period
- Reporting year 2: 4 Jul 2025 to 3 Jul 2026
- Completeness
- Published snapshot: 20,988 records in the source window 21 Aug 2026 to 19 Nov 2026. The published snapshot covers its stated source window. Older imports can extend beyond it; not every public speech is included.
This page lists the parliamentary spoken contributions we hold for Mark Garnier in the reporting year 2 (4 Jul 2025 to 3 Jul 2026). It does not include every public speech, party-conference address or constituency event. Latest retained contribution in this period: 30 Jun 2026. The source check date and dataset limits are shown above. Open the Hansard link for the full debate and surrounding context.
Read what this MP said, asked and contributed in Parliament.
269 published records · newest first.
Speeches
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
It is great to be starting what I hope will be quite a quick canter through today’s work, Sir Christopher. The Opposition welcome the broad grain of this entire Bill; it seeks to do a lot of very useful things in the pension industry across the UK. We have some contentious points, but those will not come up today. Regarding clause 1, we welcome the creation of asset pool companies.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
I will not take up too much of the Committee’s time, but suffice it to say that we all heard the evidence that was presented on Tuesday, and we in the Conservative party agree with the Liberal Democrats’ amendment. We will support it.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
I am reassured by the Minister’s comments. I beg to ask to leave to withdraw the amendment. Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
I beg to move amendment 245, in clause 2, page 3, line 39, leave out from first “in” to end of line 39. This amendment changes the definition of local investment to remove the reference to the benefit of persons living or working. This amendment runs closely with amendment 246. Amendment 245 changes the definition of local investment to remove ambiguous reference to the benefit of persons living or working in the area.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
I thank the Minister and wish him many happy returns. I hope that he has a happy birthday. We are satisfied with the Minister’s comments. I beg to ask leave to withdraw the amendment. Amendment, by leave, withdrawn. Question proposed, That the clause, as amended, stand part of the Bill.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
I have just one question for the Minister. How are the shareholdings to be decided? Will they be determined based on the size of the investment, and how will the Government decide between councils having shareholders or contracting with asset pool companies? That is my only comment.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Any decision to release surplus funds from defined-benefit pension schemes should rest firmly, as we have discussed, with the trustees. It is important to emphasise that trustees bear the ultimate responsibility for such decisions. We believe that surplus repayments to employers should be permitted only when members’ benefits are fully protected and robust safeguards are in place to maintain the security and sustainability of the scheme.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
I beg to move amendment 247, in clause 9, page 8, line 23, at end insert— “(aa) prohibiting the making of a payment unless the scheme’s assets have exceeded a buyout valuation,”. This amendment requires that surplus extraction is only permitted once buyout funding levels are achieved.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Hansard source
More
In the interest of speed, I will not speak to these amendments, other than to say that we have no objection to them.
- 4 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (Third sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
On new clause 31, as we have heard, the local government pension scheme in England and Wales has reached a record surplus of some £45 billion, which is 112% of funding levels, as of June 2024, with some estimating that it will rise to more than 125% by the end of 2025. Despite that strong funding position, no measures have been introduced to make it easier to allow councils or employers to reduce contributions or take contribution holidays.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q Thank you very much for coming to give evidence. Can I get straight into a detailed question regarding the repayment of surpluses, starting with the local government pension scheme?
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q You raise a very interesting point. Members could come up with an idea. For example, you mentioned ESG, which is a fine thing—I would not disagree with that—but sometimes it could be right to invest in something that a lot of people feel uncomfortable about, such as the arms trade or weapons manufacturers. Very sadly, they are having a bonanza at the moment, because of all the problems that are going on in Ukraine and Gaza.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q Thank you very much for coming along to give evidence this morning. I want to start with a general question: what do you see as the risks associated with surplus extraction? As we know, a lot of the funds are now in surplus, but we only need interest rates to start crashing back again—it is probably unlikely—and they could go back into deficit. Do you think the safeguards for surplus extraction are sufficient?
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q I will turn to DB pension schemes—where you have a sponsor company. For example, I have heard the British Telecom pension scheme described as a pension scheme with a telephone provider attached to it.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q Do you feel the Bill covers that management? Jack Jones: I think it puts a lot of responsibility on trustees to make that assessment. I think it is fair enough to set out the criteria under which trustees might consider surplus release—that is where you have sustained and high surpluses on quite a prudent basis.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q One thing we have not talked about is what the surplus extraction will be used for. If a host company starts taking advantage of this and they invest in building the business, most people would probably agree that that is rather a good thing. However, if they pay out dividends, is that a good thing? If they do share buy-backs, is that a good thing for the host company?
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q Could you expand a little on the technicalities of how that would work? Obviously, the trustees are there to represent the members, but they are merely a small board of individuals. If you take something like the British Telecom pension scheme—I do not know how many people are in it, but it is perhaps tens of thousands—how would a group of trustees find out what members are thinking about what they would like?
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q I agree that is an important principle, but if you are a trustee, you are potentially personally liable for any deficits, and you could get yourself in trouble. I will come on to the defined benefit pension schemes in a minute, in relation to the same point.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Hansard source
More
So do I.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q Would you be happy if the full £130 billion was released, and therefore these pension funds were right down to the wire, even if they are still technically in surplus? Patrick Coyne: I think it is highly unlikely that that scenario would happen.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Hansard source
More
Q Christopher, do you have any thoughts on that, quickly? Christopher Brooks: We do not work on final salary pensions, so I do not take a view on it.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q My last question—Chris, leap in at any point if you feel you have an answer—is about paying out surpluses, either to local government or defined benefit pension schemes.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q But is that right? Do you think that is a good use? Ultimately, as we have discussed, there is always the tricky question about how a fund could go back into deficit again. The flipside of that is that deficit then appears on the balance sheet of the host company, so there is an incentive not to raid it too much.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q Thank you. I am particularly interested to hear from the two of you, because one of the interesting things about this Bill is that we have had a lot of lobbying from the profession but very little on behalf of the members of these pension funds, who are so important. Mr Jones, if I may start with you, Unison made the point that there is a clear lack of member voice in the Bill.
- 2 Sep 2025 · Pension Schemes Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
More
Q To summarise, you are saying that the general direction of the policy, which is to get more investment into the UK and therefore more infrastructure, is not in itself a bad thing. Zoe Alexander: We absolutely support the general direction of the policy. Our members are very committed to investing more in the UK and they are doing a huge amount of work on that.
Explore activity by topic or department
Contributions by debate topic
4 Jul 2025–3 Jul 2026. Existing keyword taxonomy applied to official debate titles and contributions; a contribution may appear in more than one topic and unclassified records are retained.
View as listWhat this shows and doesn't show
Published records only — not a full account of an MP’s work. How we work →