Andrew Western MP: speeches

Andrew Western MP: full overview

4 Jul 2024–3 Jul 2025

How these years work

Our reporting years run from 4 July to 3 July, starting with the 2024 general election. They are not official parliamentary sessions. Office costs keep IPSA’s April–March financial years. Records may cover only part of a year; a missing record does not mean no work was done.

Compare reporting years, sessions and IPSA financial years.

Parliamentary contributions: dates and coverage

Source checked
19 Nov 2026
Last successful import
19 Nov 2026
Records dated through
18 Nov 2026
Selected period
Reporting year 1: 4 Jul 2024 to 3 Jul 2025
Completeness
Published snapshot: 20,988 records in the source window 21 Aug 2026 to 19 Nov 2026. The published snapshot covers its stated source window. Older imports can extend beyond it; not every public speech is included.

How to read these datesOfficial source

This page lists the parliamentary spoken contributions we hold for Andrew Western in the reporting year 1 (4 Jul 2024 to 3 Jul 2025). It does not include every public speech, party-conference address or constituency event. Latest retained contribution in this period: 23 Jun 2025. The source check date and dataset limits are shown above. Open the Hansard link for the full debate and surrounding context.

Clear speech filters

Read what this MP said, asked and contributed in Parliament.

224 published records · newest first.

Speeches

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q What is your view on its proportionality as a direct response to what has been a £35 billion challenge for the Department since covid? Given the increase in prevalence of both fraud and error—particularly fraud, which is estimate to have cost upwards of £7 billion—do you think that is a material consideration when assessing proportionality?

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Would that be the case in any preventive measure that we took in pursuit of tackling benefit fraud that did not come about as a direct result of suspicion of fraud? With anything that we try to do with the entire cohort, would we be open to that accusation?

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Thank you. I am hopeful that, through the informal conversations and the formal consultation that we are required to have on the code of practice, we will be able to set this up in such a way that everything interplays in an acceptable way. You briefly mentioned direct deduction orders. I know you have some concerns about the debt recovery power, and this is an opportunity for you to set them out.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Could I come back on the last point you made, Rick, and the suggestion that this treats disabled people as a distinct part of the population under different rules and measures. The Bill targets the three benefits that have the highest levels of fraud and error at present: universal credit, pension credit and employment and support allowance.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Hansard source
    More

    Q Thank you both for joining us today. I have an overarching question about the impact of the proposed modernisation of DWP processes and whether you think that that will improve the detection of fraud and error. Joshua Reddaway: Specifically, do you mean the EVM—eligibility verification measure—stuff?

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q It was not, but we will leave it there, because clearly you are not aware of the powers that I am referring to. You talk about the inclusion of error, as well as fraud, in what we are attempting to do here. Do you accept that there is the potential, through the effective use of the eligibility verification measure, to detect overpayments through error sooner, thereby reducing any overpayment because it would come to light earlier?

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q I suspect Minister Gould will have the bulk of the questions for you, Mark, but I have a very general question. There has, understandably, been a lot of discussion and questions today about the balance between people’s privacy and being able to prevent fraud. What is your overall view on whether the Bill strikes the necessary balance between the two? Mark Cheeseman: My view is that the Bill does strike that balance, and it tries to strike the balance.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q One more, if I may, Chair? Richard, one of the powers we intend to take is around search and seizure for the DWP when investigating serious and organised crime. That is a power that HMRC have had for some time. Can you reflect on what the benefits of that have been for HMRC’s operations, in terms of no longer needing to rely directly on the police to fulfil that function?

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q I would argue that we are accepting a different level of checking on the eligibility verification measure for everybody in receipt of those benefits. I would be perfectly happy to accept that there may be some indirect discrimination against disabled people by virtue of the fact that they are over-represented in the cohort, but are you suggesting that this would amount to direct discrimination? Rick Burgess: I think it does edge into that.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    I will not ask any more questions, but I just say to Rick that I think it might be helpful for a follow-up conversation to take place. Without wishing to get into a protracted argument, there were some things that I did not recognise as part of the Bill, but clearly that is how people are feeling and how the people you represent are feeling.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Thank you. Richard, you made a point around the existing powers that HMRC has had, since I think 2011, to request information on every interest-bearing bank account in the country, as I understand it. Could you explain what safeguards and oversight you have in place, because that feels like a similar bulk data exercise?

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Hansard source
    More

    Q To clarify, you accept that there are bulk data powers, but it is just a different cohort of people. Jasleen Chaggar: I am not aware of powers that are similar to eligibility verification notices that are exercised by the DWP. I am aware that they have similar powers in relation to direct deduction orders, and maybe that is the distinction that the witnesses earlier were making.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Thank you for joining us today, and for the engagement that we have had so far; it has been incredibly helpful and you have my assurance that it will continue. I would like to test the point that you have just set out on the POCA measure within EVM, as well as rolling that out more broadly.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Given that we have no way of knowing if somebody is in breach of the capital limit once they have given their word that that is not the case, how would you suggest that we detect that particular form of fraud where there is no suspicion of fraud because we do not know what somebody has in their bank account?

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Just to test that a little further, were we to do anything in the prevent space on fraud and error that sought to increase the safeguards and checks in place for all benefit claimants, is it your view that all of those would directly discriminate against disabled people because they are over-represented in the cohort?

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Hansard source
    More

    Q Just for clarification, is there an independent oversight mechanism in place for the use of those powers? Richard Las: I do not know, if I am honest, whether there is. I can look that up for you.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q We are looking to set a limit so the DWP would be able to deduct a maximum of 40% of an individual’s total capital as a lump sum. Would that satisfy you, or would you like us to look at that further? Eric Leenders: We would like to consider a specific de minimis. There are probably two approaches: an absolute amount or a relative amount, dependent on the individual’s essential expenditure—not their lifestyle expenditure.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Thank you for joining us. I have a couple of initial questions. You have neatly set out your position that there is no circumstance in which you would support the eligibility verification measure. I was interested when you said there are no other laws like this in the country. We heard from HMRC today about its ability to receive bulk data with regard to every interest-bearing bank account in the country, and it does that on a regular basis.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (Second sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q I have one follow-up question to each of you separately, if that is okay. Joshua, you mentioned the challenge that we have at the moment in detecting capital fraud and our reliance on somebody’s word as the only real measure that we have in place to determine that.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Alex, I have a final question regarding what you said earlier about the level of fraud you have seen remaining fairly static but you have increased your prevention measures. Which of the new measures you have stepped up have been particularly effective? Alex Rothwell: Data analysis has been particularly effective, as has getting better at recording and reporting—for example, we now have a ubiquitous case recording system that exists across the national health service.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Thank you very much for joining us today. I want to ask Dr Kassem a question, just for my own understanding. We have talked a lot about the definition of fraud and error and the Department’s approach to them. On the DWP side, to my knowledge, we are not planning to change the definitions of those within the scope of the Bill, but, clearly, we are taking new powers to enforce against them.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q On your point about scope and the level of intrusion associated with the eligibility verification measure, you said you would like to see the power restricted to the most serious investigations. From our perspective, that would run contrary to what we are trying to achieve in capturing data that enables us to identify those who we had no idea were committing fraud or in receipt of an overpayment, albeit unwittingly.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q Part of the reason that we do not have a specific intent to look at organised crime is that it makes up less than 10% of the fraud that we see in the Department—certainly of the overall fraud and error figures. I am reflecting on your comments about balance, but I am then hearing the questions about the efficacy of going to look directly into only one financial institution’s accounts. My concern is about broadening the scope.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q I will ask one more question about the systems that we have in place. What do you perceive as the principal weaknesses in the DWP’s current powers to detect fraud? Helena Wood: A really good point was made, and others who follow me in this Committee’s evidence sessions will make it as well: fraudsters rarely simply defraud the public sector or the private sector.

  • 25 Feb 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill (First sitting) · Read the full contribution in Hansard
    More

    Q I asked this question of the first panel, but I am interested, both in broad terms and specifically within the parameters of your role in the NHS, in whether you have seen changing attitudes to fraud in recent years.

Explore activity by topic or department

Contributions by debate topic

4 Jul 2024–3 Jul 2025. Existing keyword taxonomy applied to official debate titles and contributions; a contribution may appear in more than one topic and unclassified records are retained.

View as listCommunities and local government: 6Communities and local government6Culture, media and sport: 3Culture, media and sport3Defence and foreign affairs: 2Defence and foreign affairs2Democracy and constitution: 29Democracy and constitution29Economy and business: 63Economy and business63Education and skills: 5Education and skills5Environment and energy: 8Environment and energy8Health and care: 13Health and care13Housing and planning: 7Housing and planning7Immigration and borders: 3Immigration and borders3Justice and policing: 63Justice and policing63Social security and pensions: 97Social security and pensions97Transport: 5Transport5Unclassified: 60Unclassified60
What this shows and doesn't show
4 Jul 2024–3 Jul 2025. Existing keyword taxonomy applied to official debate titles and contributions; a contribution may appear in more than one topic and unclassified records are retained. Published records do not measure effort or effectiveness. Methodology.
Department or topicPublished records
Communities and local government6
Culture, media and sport3
Defence and foreign affairs2
Democracy and constitution29
Economy and business63
Education and skills5
Environment and energy8
Health and care13
Housing and planning7
Immigration and borders3
Justice and policing63
Social security and pensions97
Transport5
Unclassified60

Published records only — not a full account of an MP’s work. How we work →